Security And Safety Inside 21st Century Democracies

Tallinn experienced a security scare last week as an explosives carrying gunman threatened the staff of the Estonian Ministry of Defense.  With characteristic resolute competence, Estonian security forces ended the threat by shooting the gunman while ensuring that no innocent life was lost.  Other than the press, few people outside the capital of this peaceful and law abiding country were even aware of the dramatic and deadly event in the Ministry.  That’s both good, but also something to think about.  My family, my colleagues in our Embassy, and I are certainly enjoying the hospitality, the beauty, and the relative safety of this country.   I can’t imagine that Estonians loose a lot of sleep over the safety of their cities, towns and villages, or their homes and their families.  They have little reason to.  But as last week’s incident demonstrated, there is no such thing as “it can’t happen here.” 

In America and for Americans, as well as for many others, tragically, it has happened.  Not all that long ago, we would never have contemplated taking of our shoes off in an airport or walking through metal detectors to visit a museum.  Visiting an American Embassy was relatively easy not that long ago and and streets around our diplomatic missions were not closed off.   Tragic experience has changed all that.  We have allowed our lives to become far more complicated in exchange for greater security, not because we want to, but because we have to.  Over the years we have learned to make security precautions less intrusive and more rational.  We have also become more security conscious without being security obsessed.  In the end, we are more secure in a more dangerous world. 

The debate over how much security is enough and how much is excessive will never end in free and freedom-loving societies.  Especially when we are confronted with threats from within, rather than with outside agression, we are loath to relinguish yet another slice of physical and psychological freedom in exchange for greater protection.  We resent being shaken in the belief that our best protection are the just and democratic societies we have built.  However unsettling, the threats we face only reaffirm our most basic principles of personal liberty.  Gritting our teeth, we accept that total security is illusory and we adopt responsible management of  risks to our safety.  Depending on individual national experiences, democracies pass through these resentment and realization phases at their own pace — but inevitably arrive at similar conclusions.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under American Values, Civil Society, good governance, Peace and Security

2 responses to “Security And Safety Inside 21st Century Democracies

  1. Ambassador Polt, How correct you are in pointing out the overall security well-being in Estonia. While in estonia I have never felt threatened by any Estonian citizen or in fact another persons. I went to the regular tourist locations. While I did feel Security precautions were being taken, at no time did I feel uncomfortable. I still encourage my neighbors and co-workers to consider taking their next vacation in Estoni. At present six different frinds have visited Estonia for vacations. It is ironic the most difficult part of their trips were finding flights to Tallinn.
    Not one person every felt anything other than Estonia was worth their time and money to visit.
    That level of a comfort zone has to come from the Estonian people themselves.
    It is not simply a matter of more policing but a matter of people feeling welcome in a country.
    Sincerely,
    William Cline

  2. Ambassador Polt,
    There is a VERY informative artice in the August 15, 2011 “GOVERNMENT EXECUTIVE regarding Estonia as their estonian President, Toomas Hendrik Ilves sees things covering the past, the present, and the future of computing in Estonia :
    http://www.govexec.com/features/0811-15/0811-15s6.htm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s